Close-rate history
How often they actually close, checked against their history.
26.9% national in-home close rate
across 53,389 recorded consultations
The roles
Most painting companies hire for one of two seats. The estimator prices and sells the job. The sales manager runs the estimators, and often still runs estimates too.
Walks the house inside and out, measures, writes the scope, prices it from your production rates and sells the job at the kitchen table. Brings color and product options, and follows up on every open estimate.
Step 1
Trade, territory, lead sources, average ticket and your pay plan. A short call or a two-minute form.
Step 2
We go after the top reps at the strongest companies in your trade and market, people with a proven track record, and make the case for joining you.
Step 3
Close rate, average ticket, earnings and references, all checked before anyone reaches your shortlist.
Step 4
You meet the shortlist and make the call. We help you set the pay plan.
Benchmarks
No one publishes an industry close rate for painting. Here's one painting company's target, next to in-home close rates across trades.
Checked before you meet them
We ask each rep for their own numbers on these before you meet them: appointments a week, close rate, average ticket and actual earnings. Then we check references.
Win rate: Textbook Painting. Close rates: Siro, Apr-Aug 2026. Counts: BLS, May 2025.
Pay reality
What W-2 sales reps at painting and wall covering contractors earn, per BLS. Most estimators are paid partly on commission, so lead flow and win rate move the number.
Not in these numbers
NoteCommission-only 1099 reps. Top earners make more.
Total annual pay (base + commission)
BLS, May 2025
When to hire
In most markets, exterior work runs on the weather. The estimator you hire in winter knows your pricing before the spring calls start.
Leads going unrun right now?
See what an empty seat costsFAQ
A painting estimator is a painting company's in-home salesperson. They walk the house inside and out, measure, write the scope, price the job and sell it to the homeowner, usually at the kitchen table.
We question every candidate on the appointments they run each week, their close rate, their average ticket and what they actually earned, and we call their references. If the numbers don't add up, they don't reach you. You still run your own interview, and we suggest a ride-along before any offer.
In most residential painting companies, nothing. The estimator walks the house, measures, prices the job and sells it. BLS counts 3,680 cost estimators and 2,010 sales reps on W-2 payrolls at painting contractors, so the title tells you little. When you hire, ask whether the person closed jobs or only priced them.
Only if you can get to every one fast. If you're pricing jobs at night after a full day with the crews, the estimates you don't get to are jobs you don't win. A good handoff: give a new estimator your paid leads first, and keep the referrals and repeat customers until they've learned your pricing.
Percent of sale is the simplest plan: 6-8% of sales is the range painting owners hear most, per Michael Murray of Textbook Painting. Percent of gross profit makes a discount cost the estimator too; his worked example pays 12% of gross profit. Most plans add a salary. About 50% of total pay is his company's target.
There's no industry standard. Textbook Painting's bonus target is a win rate of 40-45%, depending on the rep's experience. Your own lead mix matters more than any benchmark, so judge a new hire against it, and ask every estimator what their number was counted from.
Someone who already sells the work you sell. A residential repaint is sold in the home, to the homeowner, often in one visit. New construction and commercial painting are bid to builders, general contractors and property managers, which is a different job. We recruit for the in-home seat, so we headhunt estimators who already sell repaints to homeowners.
That's your call, and one to check with your accountant, because classification depends on how the job is run. Either way, the estimator is hired directly by your company, not by Level.
We aim to have a first candidate in front of you within 7 days of getting your job description. A typical hire takes 21 days. Both vary by market, and hiring in February is a different search from hiring in June.
Yes, both sales managers who still run estimates and those who only lead the team. We vet them the same way: appointments run, close rate, average ticket, actual earnings and references.
Yes. We've placed reps with CertaPro Painters, and we've made 1,000+ placements across home service companies.
If you don't like them within 60 days of hiring, we'll replace them totally free.